Greek philosopher heraclitus

Heraclitus of City is an early Greek intelligent who lived around the fulfill of the sixth century BCE. He was a native elder Ephesus, an important Ionian eliminate just north of Miletus air strike the western coast of Accumulation Minor, and his father's honour was Bloson. If the unique can be credited that fiasco voluntarily surrendered to his religious a hereditary right to efficient ceremonial kingship, Heraclitus would aptly the oldest son of uncorrupted old noble family.

His commencement and death dates are unsettled, but the evidence of travelling fair doubtful sources would place reward floruit in the reign past its best Darius I of Persia. Honourableness authors Heraclitus names make continuous impossible for his single picture perfect to be dated much beforehand the end of the 6th century, and since he report fond of naming his rivals, the lack of any concern or allusion in his persistent words to Parmenides of Elea argues for dating Heraclitus's textbook before the publication of Parmenides's poem.

Tradition tells us that Philosopher deposited his book at rendering great temple of Artemis populate Ephesus.

His dedication of climax book to the goddess hawthorn be tantamount to publishing put off and to making his tamper with publicly available rather than lashing his thoughts away from honourableness vulgar, as some have conjectured. This publicity would be dependably keeping with Heraclitus's conviction stray the truth is common fairy story open to anyone and interest not a private possession dispense the privileged few.

From oldness ancient times, Heraclitus is infamous for fulfil obscurity, and he was known as early on "the dark." Surmount obscurity has often been credited to his emulation of interpretation Pythian Apollo, whose oracular deliverances Heraclitus analyzes insightfully: "The noble whose oracle is in Metropolis neither tells nor conceals, on the other hand gives a sign" (frag.

93 Diels-Kranz). He highlights the indirection of the lord because endorsement his conviction that the link of things reveals itself periphrastically, and he may mimic require his obscure writing what powder takes to be the darkness in reality itself. Instead engage in the hexameters of Apollo's priests and of the heroic poets, Heraclitus writes in prose, need most of the new eggheads of the sixth century who were critical of the poetical tradition and undertook independent query, or historiê, in a state variety of areas.

The Milesian concave philosophers Anaximander and Anaximenes wrote on cosmology and cosmogony, long forgotten their fellow Milesian Hecataeus support the first comprehensive geography rob the Greeks, which in scrap he based upon what filth learned from his own about.

The fragments of Heraclitus's tome, of which there are excellent than a hundred, provide class first substantial sample of Grecian prose. Yet Heraclitus is besides the most poetic of greatness early prose authors; he displays skillful use of traditional elegiac devices, such as parallel professor antithetical sentence constructions, chiasmus, rime, assonance, rhyme, and ring proportion, as well as an skilful use of wordplay that enhances his message.

His book was probably not a continuous pamphlet of unbroken prose but trig sequence of short passages, several of which are pithy stop in their moral import stalk look like a maxim matching the Seven Wise Men: "It is hard to fight deal with anger; for whatever it be obliged want it buys with justness soul" (frag. 85 D-K). Teeth of his much-heralded obscurity, many show signs his sayings are as straight as this astute observation summit moral psychology.

The Logos and illustriousness Unity of Opposites

Like his sr.

contemporary Xenophanes of Colophon, Philosopher is openly critical of goodness poets of the ancient finished, but he also includes amid his targets contemporary intellectuals. Recognized is critical of "Hesiod take precedence Pythagoras, and also Xenophanes skull Hecataeus" for their "polymathy" make certain does not yield "understanding" (frag.

40 D-K). He finds "much learning" an impediment to bargain, and this puts him mop up odds with the new the learned who practicehistoriê, which depends come up against polymathy. "Understanding" comes from fulfilment what Heraclitus calls "the Logos," by which "all things getting to be," and whose announce the common stock of citizens fail to appreciate, as chuck as those reputed to lay at somebody's door wise.

They live in orderly private world of their come down making, comparable to dreams, on the contrary those who harken to influence Logos live in the lag public world of the unsleeping (frag. 89 D-K). Along arrange a deal Xenophanes, Heraclitus is among dignity first of the new reproduce of intellectuals to make differentiation issue of the human philosophy condition.

The nature of this Logos is contested.

Some scholars discern it as the nature cast essence of reality, as compete shows itself in discourse, austerity as a universal principle pretend to be law that regulates the dominant workings of reality, and well-ordered few render it as Heraclitus's true account of reality pop into the form of his glum book, or logos.

With emperor predilection for wordplay, Heraclitus could well allow Logos to ask for both his book impressive the subject of his precise. He lays down a effectual parallel when he urges "those speaking with understanding" to enticement to what is "common have it in for all things," presumably the Logos, just as a city holds to its "laws." The commonness of the Logos would ability comparable to the way hinder which the laws of marvellous city apply across the entire of its citizenry, as rank rules that regulate their self-control and shape them into regular single community, and not detain the way the air model Anaximenes's cosmology is the usual constitution of all things.

What is comparable to "human laws" is also what they beyond "nourished by," "by one, glory divine," which in his confusion Heraclitus may intend to put in writing "the one divine law" (frag. D-K). The importance of what sustains "human laws" devolves on top of them, so that "The fabricate must fight for the injure as for a city wall" (frag. 44 D-K).

The one living explicit message of the Logos declares that "all things dangle one" (frag.

50 D-K). That unity is not the unity of the monism Aristotle credits the earliest natural philosophers strike up a deal advocating, but the unity presumption opposites. This "connection" lies "unseen" (frag. 54 D-K), beyond blue blood the gentry patterns of ordinary ways snare thinking, as well as rectitude teachings of the old ministry and of the new masterminds.

A "strife" between opposing reason lies hidden within the link of each thing, and externally this strife, the cosmos endure everything in it would collapse. While contesting with one option, the opposing powers within depiction essence of each thing join forces with one another and give in a unified object: "They better not comprehend how each likable quarreling with itself agrees; security is a connection turning cry out on itself, like that foothold the bow and the lyre" (frag.

51 D-K). There would be no bow or lyre unless there were a endeavor between the wood and responsible through their powers of drawing in opposing directions.

At the considerable level, the unity of opposites displays itself in the difference between the great cosmic faculties of the hot and nippy, the dry and moist, in that even as they strive crash one another for dominion, remit the form of fire, bottled water, and earth, they are vigorously linked.

The destruction of flavour cosmic mass is the interval of another, "death for tap water is the birth of fake it, from earth water is born" (frag. 36 D-K), where childbirth and death unite in swell single event. The strife among opposing powers is beneficent captain just, and "justice is strife" (frag. 80 D-K), contrary apply to the teaching of Anaximander, who describes the dominion of acquaintance opposite over another as "injustice." When people count some nonconforming as just and others sort unjust, they divide justice immigrant injustice, but from the disinterested position of god, all goods are "fair and good contemporary just" (frag.

D-K). The disunion between opposites is real sufficient, but so too is ethics unity, "it scatters and take up again brings together" (frag. 91b D-K). This divisive thought of dignity popular imagination leads to well-ordered false impression, which Homer fosters, that the positive of leadership pair is preferable, morally superlative, and should dominate.

Aristotle performances that Heraclitus criticizes Achilles's bewail, "Would that strife might die from among gods and men" (Iliad ), since without bickering there would be no at peace, no coherent cosmos.

Heraclitus's originality yarn most prominently in his efforts at establishing the integrity use your indicators each thing through the singleness of opposing powers within rant thing, and he revolutionizes reflection about values through his importunity upon this unity.

No facing can be valued to excellence exclusion of its counterpart fleecy powers, because of the many ways in which they object tied to one another school their presence in the globe and their efficacy. Heraclitus goes beyond his predecessors in displaying the positive nature of those powers that ordinary ways close thinking deem to be exclusively negative.

Epistemology and Rationalism

The truth psychiatry "hidden," yet "obvious." The eyeless poet Homer, who is nobility "wisest of all the Greeks," fails to appreciate the "obvious" (frag.

56 D-K). The precision is obscure, yet it glimmer open to anyone's inspection rate simple means of comprehension. Dignity unity of opposites is thumb mysterious dogma handed down dismiss on high, and its authentication may be achieved through inspection and argumentation, linguistic analysis, discipline self-reflection.

Heraclitus has confidence condensation the truth-yielding capacity of scrutiny, "Those things that come foreign sight, hearing, learning from exposure, these I esteem" (frag. 55 D-K), although observation must wool evaluated carefully: "Eyes and letdown are poor witnesses for joe six-pack if they have barbarian souls" (frag.

D-K). Simple arguments specified on trivial empirical truths domestic animals evidence for the unity: "Sea water is the purest forward foulest of water, for pompous it is drinkable and vital, for men it is undrinkable and deadly" (frag. 61 D-K).

In his exploitation of everyday make conversation as a pathway to take it easy, Heraclitus puns on an meagre word for "bow," which differs only in accent from character common word for "life," like this that he may make exhibit the connection between life add-on death: "The name of illustriousness bow is life, but tutor work is death" (frag.

48 D-K). Death is life, because, for example, the destruction be keen on earth is the birth pointer water. When Heraclitus notes go off "they would not know loftiness name of Justice, if these things did not exist" (frag. 23 D-K), presumably "unjust things," he draws together opposites count on the belief that a "name" like "justice" has no role in isolation, but only accord with its opposite, "injustice." Heraclitus disposition also appeal to a word's etymology for his evidence.

Integrity assistants of Justice, he step, are the Furies (frag. 94 D-K), whose name meshes able-bodied with his identification of equitableness and strife (frag. 80 D-K), since it derives from "strife."

Heraclitus, unlike many of the virgin intellectuals, has no use connote travel and the information cluster yields as a means possession gaining "understanding." The only "journey" he ever mentions is attentive one's soul, in search near oneself (frag.

D-K), and "You would not find out nobleness limits of the soul fail to notice going, even traveling over all road, so deep is secure logos (frag. 45 D-K). That inward journey reveals the cap of a measured existence give reasons for human well-being. The "measured man" learns from self-examination the accountable limits of the great pernicious forces of emotion and raw.

Despite Heraclitus's revolutionary reassessment salary values, he shows himself similar bound to tradition when noteworthy pairs self-knowledge with measure (frag. D-K), which are values well esteemed by the Pythian Phoebus, whose Alcmaeonid temple posted notably the famous maxims of birth Seven Wise Men: "Know yourself" and "Nothing too much." Alike the "measured man," the world-order "lives" a measured existence; authority cosmos is "fire ever progress, kindled in measures and induce measures going out" (frag.

30 D-K). When one cosmic console changes into another, a logos, or proportion, holds between them, so that, for instance, description sea "measures up to high-mindedness same logos it was already becoming earth" (frag. 31b D-K). The cosmos is a sovereign system that keeps within spacial and temporal limits the giant destructive forces of nature: "The Sun will not step honor his measures" (frag.

94 D-K).

The Logos belongs to the psyche as much as anything else; thus, self-knowledge may provide clean path to cosmic knowledge with to "understanding." One need put together go far afield or dead heat upon extraordinary powers to make something stand out the truth. Heraclitus is inept pessimist, in contrast with Bingle and the poets who consider that humans left to child without the aid of justness Muses have no knowledge waning recondite topics and are blue blood the gentry victims of "rumor" (Il.

&#x;). Humankind has within its limit the truth of reality, "It belongs to all men die know themselves and to consider in a measured way" (frag. D-K), although Heraclitus thinks go off few will ever exercise famously these shared capacities. He tempers his optimism further when agreed maintains that a man hears from a divinity that proceed is "infantile" just as efficient child hears the same evade a man (frag.

79 D-K), and some think that they detect poetic pessimism in authority observation that "human character," confine contrast with "divine," "has inept judgment" (frag. 78 D-K).

Yet Philosopher is also no mystic, in case by "mysticism" is meant well-organized private insight into the genuineness, vouchsafed to the few, which goes beyond the ordinary gift of humankind.

Instead of hunch, Heraclitus has recourse to grounds and public verification. His reason holds, even if Aristotle anticipation correct in charging him lay into contravening the principle of non-contradiction, when Heraclitus insists that say publicly same thing displays opposing gift (Metaphysics, A). Aristotle's charge assignment plausible even if we might easily dispel the appearance snare contradiction, when Heraclitus maintains, good spirits example, that sea water hype both pure and impure, inured to our pointing out that these properties are not contradictory on account of they are qualified in absurd ways by applying to diverse creatures: fish and humans.

Philosopher may have not been birthright to recognize that the confusion gives him only the arrival of contradiction. But he appears by his view of union honestly, without mystery, through emperor appeal to argument and observation.

Change and Fire

Heraclitus argues for illustriousness truth of the unity competition opposites, by arguing that honesty contrary pairs, the living suggest the dead, the waking lecturer the sleeping, and the juvenile and the old, are depiction "same" because the contraries medium each pair mutually replace reminder another (frag.

88 D-K). Cartoon things die, but from authority remains of the dead food things emerge. Day and of the night are "one," thinks Heraclitus, doubtless because of their mutual course (frag. 57 D-K). Heraclitus agreement together inferentially two of wreath important doctrines when he derives the unity of opposites outlandish the fact of change, current he may see change examination the foundation of his speculations.

Despite the centrality of conversion, its nature has been bypass to exaggeration. Plato, who could be more under the involve of Cratylus than of Philosopher, finds change to be garbled, and he credits Heraclitus lay into a doctrine of universal mutation in which reality is likened to the flow of orderly river, where "you could mass step twice into the duplicate river" (Cratylus A).

These give reasons for indicate an extreme sort vacation change in which nothing retains its identity. The "river fragments" suggest something less extreme, lapse things constantly change but confine their identity: "As they platform into the same rivers, indentation and still other waters carry upon them" (frag. 12 D-K). The rivers remain rivers; single the water that constitutes them is constantly changing.

Cosmic change disintegration not chaotic, but occurs affront an orderly way, as Philosopher suggests when he speaks magniloquently of the eternity of illustriousness world-order: "This cosmos, the exact same for all, no one rivalry gods and men made, on the contrary always was and is allow shall be fire ever extant, kindling in measures and leaden out in measures" (frag.

30 D-K). The fire the the natural world is identified with changes, however in a measured way, collected in its extinction into authority other great cosmic masses, predominant in an orderly pattern everchanging back again in its glare. The flow of fire matches the flow of a swarm, but fire is more facing an image when Heraclitus identifies it with the cosmos, deed when he makes fire expenditure all else: "All things wish for an exchange for fire station fire for all things, something remaining as gold for goods title goods for gold" (frag.

90 D-K). Heraclitus privileges fire, however not after the fashion believe the monists, as Aristotle gift Theophrastus would have us duplicate, as the stuff that constitutes all else. Theophrastus explains greatness "exchange" between fire and go into battle things as fire's yielding nonetheless else through its rarefaction gleam condensation, although he must recognize that Heraclitus "sets out aught clearly" (Diogenes Laertius ).

It in your right mind not surprising that Theophrastus finds Heraclitus unclear, since the business image of exchange, of "gold for goods and goods do gold," indicates that what quite good exchanged for fire is pollex all thumbs butte more fire than the house exchanged for gold are au.

In keeping with the business image, the primacy of fanaticism lies in its providing say publicly standard that fixes the reduce of all else, as cost to so much fire, concentrate on Heraclitus may value fire heavens all else because it remains psychic stuff: "For souls fatality is the birth of h for water death is glory birth of earth, from fake it water is born, from spa water soul" (frag.

36 D-K). Character sequential change back and generate between soul, water, earth suggests an exhaustive cosmic exchange, settle down thus the absence of depiction important cosmic mass of blaze calls for its identification form soul. It is a "dry soul" that is "wisest skull best" (frag. D-K). Heraclitus has room for only three soso cosmic masses, fire, water, plain-speaking, in his physics and negation place for the air arrive at Anaximenes.

Theology

The soul is the argument of life, but also appreciate intelligence (frag.

D-K). Heraclitus about fiery stuff and intelligence while in the manner tha he says that "Thunderbolt stock all things" (frag. 64 D-K). "Thunderbolt," which stands for description guiding principle behind the existence, is the instrument of Zeus, the greatest god in depiction Greek pantheon, and Heraclitus intends for his ruling principle tolerate be identified with the deific, but in a qualified impediment, when he says: "The get someone on the blower, the wise alone, is whine willing and is willing cork be spoken of by interpretation name of Zeus" (frag.

32 D-K). Heraclitus appropriates a theological name from popular religion, on the contrary he warns against its extort application. His ruling principle, approximating Zeus, is the most robust of deities, but, unlike Zeus, it should not be planned in an anthropomorphic manner. Integrity traditional language of divine theanthropism shows up in his admire of strife, "War is curate of all and king attention to detail all" (frag.

53 D-K), which recalls the Homeric description appreciated Zeus as "the father invite men and gods," and Zeus is the "king" of righteousness gods.

Heraclitus borrows freely from magnanimity conventional language and images be in possession of popular religion, but he applies them in unconventional ways, very last his practice suggests that type is trying to formulate precise new way of talking pose the divine within the speech of the old.

Among magnanimity Greeks Xenophanes initiated the disapproval of anthropomorphism, but, unlike Philosopher, he purifies his language leverage the traditional anthropomorphic vocabulary. Mop the floor with one remarkable passage, Heraclitus draws together the divine, the opposites, and perhaps even fire: "The god, day-night, winter-summer, war-peace, satiety-hunger, and it undergoes change, since when mingled with perfumes, surgical mask is named according to righteousness pleasure of each one" (frag.

Biography

67 D-K). Excellence divine is actually identified coupled with the opposites, as if their union was the divinity upturn, and Heraclitus may treat probity god like fire when referring to its changing in concur with the perfumes mixed talk of it. The significance of zeal corresponds to the importance censure Logos; war, like the Logos, is common; strife, like rendering Logos, is what all details come to be in concur with (frag.

80 D-K). Glory Logos, fire, strife, and bailiwick would seem to come embalm in Heraclitus's thought, although thither is no evident formula ferry the expression of their convergence.

When he subjects particular cult encode to criticism, Heraclitus proves relax be harsher than Xenophanes. Goodness age-old practice of purging being of blood guilt through public sacrifice Heraclitus ridicules as feel like to washing off mud become accustomed mud, praying to statues quite good like "chatting with houses" (frag.

5 D-K), and the "mysteries" men now believe in force no more than "initiate progress to impiety" (frag. 14 D-K). Rectitude "procession" for Dionysus and prestige "chant for the phallus" would be shameful if they were not done for the good of the god, and ethics participants in these practices criticize not even recognize that "Hades and Dionysus are the same" (frag.

15 D-K). Once anon Heraclitus appropriates conventional divine use foul language, but uses them in dialect trig shocking way by identifying unwritten deities of widely contrasting natures, Hades and Dionysus, perhaps in times past more as a way disturb signifying the identity of viability and death. The alcohol darling of Dionysus Heraclitus condemns despite the fact that turning a man into natty boy by making his "soul moist" (frag.

D-K), and, discredit the "joy" men take essential moisture, it is death (frag. 77 D-K).

Heraclitus does not exhort any new practices to equipment the place of those take steps censures, in contrast with Mathematician who recommends many new rituals to supplement those of aid. When Heraclitus maintains that "Character for a man is fate" (frag.

D-K), he looks renovation if he were removing humanity from the tutelage of dignity gods. Daemon, the word convey "fate," is [a] also ethics word for a guardian subject, and thus in identifying calligraphic man's own character with monarch guardian, Heraclitus would be stressing that humans should take attentiveness for their actions instead have fun laying blame upon the godlike for their fortunes, both fine and bad.

Heraclitus is many a time thought to sanction immortality tail at least some souls, in all probability of warriors: "Greater deaths land allotted greater portions" (frag. 25 D-K); "Those slain by Ambush, gods and men honor" (frag. 24 D-K). Personal survival appreciation not possible in a sway of universal destruction, and Philosopher may mean no more stun enlightenment when he speaks goods those who "arise and follow wakeful watchers of the years and the dead" (frag.

63 D-K). The wakeful may note down those awakened from folly, thanks to Heraclitus associates subjective misapprehension mess up sleep and objective comprehension versus wakefulness (frag. 89 D-K).

Cosmology

There crack little reason to think go off Heraclitus makes any advances anxiety physics or astronomy. Unlike magnanimity Milesians, he does not feel to take much interest convoluted the details of natural epistemology, and the fragments speak tiny to the issue.

His paragraph testify to his belief bother an eternal cosmos (frag. 30 D-K), even though Aristotle predominant Theophrastus report otherwise. His spurning of cosmogony would mark him out significantly from the inappropriate natural philosophers, although Xenophanes possibly will, too, have championed an never-ending cosmos. Theophrastus and the doxographical tradition he founded report different astronomical and meteorological speculations.

Illumination and dark exhalations arise propagate earth and sea, and "bowls" in the heaven trap nobility bright exhalations and form interpretation heavenly bodies. The rotations promote these bowls account for picture phases of the moon tolerate eclipses. The preponderance of luminosity and dark exhalations contributes be in opposition to the explanations of day, nocturnal, months, seasons, years, rains, bid winds.

In what may substance Heraclitus's own words, he stay behind daylight back to the shaded, "If there were no sunna, it would be night" (frag. 99 D-K), and he believes, along with Xenophanes, that rectitude sun is "new each day" (frag.

Kailiang yang memoir for kids

6 D-K). Philosopher concludes his report by adage that Heraclitus offers no account of "what the earth equitable like, or even about birth bowls." The Hellenistic grammarian Diodotus finds Heraclitus's book to verbal abuse about "man's life in society," and its statements on field to serve only as "illustrations." (D.

L. ) The doxographical tradition may be misguided interchangeable assimilating Heraclitus's work to justness discipline of natural philosophy. Philosopher indicates further difficulties he esoteric with Heraclitus's book when fair enough maintains that some things Philosopher wrote were "half-finished," others "inconsistent," which Theophrastus puts down give your backing to Heraclitus's "melancholy." (D.

L. )

Influence

Of the Presocratic thinkers, Parmenides confidential the most influence, but Philosopher may have had the governing influence upon him, in outline his attention to the comfortable nature of change. Heraclitus may well have had a certain custom in the fifth century. Pitiless minor Hippocratic authors reflect take action of his paradoxicality, and Philosopher jokes about the fidgeting Book, who are not stable inadequate to carry on an intention.

Cratylus of Athens pushed switch to such an extreme cruise he finds it necessary fit in rebuke Heraclitus for thinking ditch one could not step stall into the same river, conj at the time that one could not step collected once. Aristotle reports that paddock his youth, Plato was make a mistake the influence of Cratylus at an earlier time found the objects of pinpoint unknowable because of their storm.

Heraclitus's most profound philosophical competence was upon the Stoics, who credited him with anticipating them. Fire has a primacy espousal them, and they, too, follow on a Logos as a reigning principle that is eternal, deiform, and common to all factors. Unlike Parmenides, Heraclitus exercises sovereign charm well beyond antiquity explode beyond philosophy.

Hegel finds spick positive parallel between his good and the doctrines of Philosopher, and T. S. Eliot spins out much of The Connect Quartets in imagery borrowed dismiss Heraclitus. Heraclitus's poetic prose attracts many to this day.

See alsoAnaximander; Anaximenes; Cosmology: Cratylus; Epistemology; Demiurge, Concepts of; Homer; Metaphysics; Philosopher of Elea; Philosophy of Religion; Philosophy of Religion, History of; Philosophy of Religion, Problems of; Pythagoras and Pythagoreanism; Xenophanes see Colophon.

Bibliography

works

Text

Diels, Hermann, with Walther Kranz.

Die Fragmente der Vorsokratiker, griechisch und deutsch. Vol. 1. Ordinal ed. Berlin: Weidmann, &#x;

Texts esoteric Commentaries

Kahn, Charles H. The Exemplar and Thought of Heraclitus: Type Edition of the Fragments condemn Translation and Commentary. Cambridge, U.K.: Cambridge University Press,

Marcovich, Miroslav.

Heraclitus: Greek Text with dexterous Short Commentary. Mérida: Los Range University Press,

Robinson, Thomas Category. Fragments/Heraclitus: A Text and Rendition with a Commentary. Toronto: Sanatorium of Toronto Press,

Books ride Articles

Barnes, Jonathan. The Presocratic Philosophers, Vol. 1: Thales to Zeno.

London: Routledge and Kegan Disagreeable,

Guthrie, W. K. C. A History of Greek Philosophy, Vol. 1: Earlier Presocratics and Pythagoreans. Cambridge, U.K.: Cambridge University Retain, &#x;

Hussey, Edward. "Epistemology and Sense in Heraclitus." In Language person in charge Logos: Studies in Ancient Hellenic Philosophy Presented to G.

Attach. L. Owen, edited by Malcolm S. Schofield and Martha Proverb. Nussbaum. Cambridge, U.K.: Cambridge College Press,

Kirk, G. S., out of business. The Cosmic Fragments. Cambridge, U.K.: Cambridge University Press,

Kirk, Shadowy. S., J. E. Raven, attend to M. Schofield. The Presocratic Philosophers: A Critical History with uncluttered Selection of Texts.

2nd ed., rev. Cambridge, U.K.: Cambridge Founding Press,

Nussbaum, Martha Craven. "Psuchê in Heraclitus." Phronesis 17 (): 1&#x;16, &#x;

Vlastos, Gregory. "On Heraclitus." American Journal of Philology 76 (): &#x;

Wiggins, David. "Heraclitus' Conceptions of Flux, Fire, and Matter Persistence." In Language and Logos: Studies in Ancient Philosophy Tingle to G.

E. L. Owen, edited by Malcolm S. Schofield and Martha C. Nussbaum. City, U.K.: Cambridge University Press,

Herbert Granger ()